Tag Archives: edith wharton

Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton – Book Review

Ethan FromeEthan Frome by Edith Wharton
Age: Adult
Genre: Fiction
Source: My copy
Publisher: Scribner Library, 1911
181 pages
Find this book at your local library

Ethan Frome is a rather sad and depressing tale set in the small and fictional New England town of Starkfield. The novella beings with the narrator’s first introduction to Ethan Frome, a lonely and reserved old man in town. After Ethan chauffeurs the narrator to and from various engagements, the author learns about Ethan’s history, and more prominently, his doomed love story.

This book is by leaps and bounds different from Age of Innocence. Its much shorter for one thing, (181 pages!), and the story isn’t bogged down with elaborate descriptions of social mores, norms and etiquette. This story felt much more raw and truthful.

That doesn’t mean that Wharton did not impress with her use of language and description. She was able to shed a favorable light on one of the most disliked characters, Ethan’s wife Zenobia. Even Ethan, the purported protagonist came across as idle and impotent in his actions to save the fate of his wife’s cousin and house-help Mattie.Each character was flawed in their own unique way. The ending sort of threw me for a loop. I didn’t see it coming, and it was rather depressing in how it all played out for Zenobia, Ethan and Mattie.

I think if I had read this first, I might have been more open to Age of Innocence. Finishing Ethan Frome left me wanting more. More cultural analysis, more historical context of an era long-gone, and more of Wharton’s story-telling.

The Age of Innocence – Review

Spread the word

The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton
Age: Teen and up
Genre: Fiction
Location: New York

Set in the early 1900’s in New York, The Age of Innocence is a story about love, betrayal, etiquette and social norms. Newland Archer is the typical upperclass New Yorker, set to wed May Wellend. When May’s cousin Madame Ellen Olenska comes to the New York seeking refuge from her husband in France, Newland’s views of his ideal world begin to tear as he discovers a new way of living and thinking through Ellen.

Edith Wharton’s classic is much like Pride and Prejudice; filled with social commentary and distaste for elitist norms and customs. It did, however, lack the wit and humor that made Pride and Prejudice a fun read. Don’t get me wrong, I did enjoy Age of Innocence, particularly towards the end. The first half was very dry and very, very little happened. Most of the first half was laying the foundation for the future relationship between Newland and Ellen. I did enjoy Wharton’s descriptions of New York during that era, and the personalities she crafted that embodied certain archetypes of the time.

May Wellend represents naive innocence (not seeing any reason or cause to change), Newland represents trapped innocence (wanting to change, but unable to), Ellen lacks all innoncence as she represents change.

The book is also ripe with Wharton’s frustrations with American customs in regards to traditions, appearance and social class. Although Wharton herself comes from upper class of New York, I think this gives her an insider’s perspective of the lifestyle that she mocks in this story.

The girls in my bookclub were very unsatisfied with the final ending between Newland and Ellen Olenska, but I liked it. I have a bias towards the not-so-happy endings. They seem more realistic to me. I did think that the ending was incredibly rushed through, when compared to the rest of the book. So much happened in the last 20 pages, and it took the first 140 to lay all the groundwork.

I do want to read more of Wharton, I love learning about the elite New York aristrocrasies that reigned over classic New York. I think this book would be a logical step up from fans of Anna Godberson’s The Luxe series, although Age of Innocence lacks the intense drama and raw passion that carries The Luxe series. Age of Innocence is a more quiet, subtle and accurate portrayal of this era.

This book was read for the OATES Challenge as well as the Read, Remember, Recommend Challenge.

The Age of Innocence
by Edith Wharton
The Modern Library Classics, 1920
ISBN 0375753206
270 pages


Find this book at your local library